Gut Health Drinks
Gut health drinks, particularly kombucha, kefir, and bone broth, have achieved celebrity status in wellness culture. These fermented or collagen-rich beverages are marketed as solutions for bloating, gut issues, energy crashes, dull skin or general “resetting.”
These drinks are usually marketed as a shortcut to a healthier gut, often promising benefits within days. But gut health is complex, and the claims made about these drinks are often oversimplified or exaggerated. While they can be useful tools, the evidence is substantially more modest than marketing suggests, and they are not substitutes for foundational dietary changes. Additionally, quality and individual tolerance vary enormously.
This guide breaks down what gut health drinks can and can’t do, where the hype comes from and when they may actually worsen symptoms.
What are the claims about gut health drinks?
Gut health drinks claim to permanently rebalance the microbiome, reduce bloating, heal the gut lining, boost immunity, clear skin, support detoxification and improve your mood. Results are promised to be visible within days or weeks with these drinks replacing the need for other dietary interventions. But many of these claims are built on tiny pieces of evidence mixed with a lot of hopeful marketing.
Where these claims originate
The marketing of kombucha and kefir has leveraged legitimate science around probiotics and fermented foods. Bone broth marketing draws from traditional food wisdom and the valid concept that collagen supports connective tissue.
However, these claims have been massively amplified with modest research findings having become 'cures,' temporary effects have become permanent transformations, and individual variation has been erased in favour of universal claims.
Wellness influencers and supplement companies have heavily invested in promoting these products as solutions for acne, digestive issues, and hormonal dysfunction.
The problem is that the marketing for all these categories tends to:
exaggerate the quantity of beneficial bacteria
misuse the term 'gut healing'
apply broad claims to products that weren’t studied
ignore individual gut differences
create unrealistic expectations
What does the evidence show?
Kombucha - Kombucha contains organic acids (acetic acid, glucuronic acid), probiotics (if not pasteurised), and bioactive compounds from tea. It theoretically provides antimicrobial activity and modulates inflammation. But a 2024 study of healthy participants consuming kombucha for 4 weeks found no significant changes to inflammation and only very subtle changes in the gut microbiome. Importantly 31% reported gastrointestinal discomfort.
Kefir - Kefir contains multiple probiotic strains and bioactive compounds. Animal studies show it has potential for reducing inflammation, lowering cholesterol, and supporting immunity. But limited human trials exist. It's important to consider that kefir quality varies dramatically. Commercial kefir often contains added sugars and may be heat-treated (killing probiotics). If you do want to give kefir a go then homemade or high-quality kefir without added sugar is substantially more beneficial.
Bone broth - Bone broth contains collagen, gelatin, and minerals from the extended simmering of bones. It theoretically supports gut lining integrity and provides readily available amino acids. But there are very few trials on humans that specifically examine bone broth. Most evidence comes from animal studies or theoretical reasoning due to it's collagen content and mineral levels. Bone broth is not a substitute for varied protein intake though as it is lacking in some amino acids. Its actual collagen content is similar to other gelatin-rich foods (such as chicken skin or jiggly cuts of meat). Marketing often positions it as uniquely restorative, but there is insufficient evidence to support this claim.
In general any improvements in bloating or digestive symptoms tend to come from hydration or meal changes. People feel better simply because they are increasing their fluid intake, slowing down when drinking or replacing fizzy soft drinks.
When is it ok to drink gut health drinks?
If you enjoy the flavour of these drinks and find that it increases your hydration or reduces your reliance on sugary drinks, without any adverse side effects, then small amounts can be an enjoyable addition to a balanced diet. The modest microbiota changes documented are not harful, but these drinks should not be positioned as a digestive cure or essential health intervention.
When to be cautious
Gut health drinks may not be the best choice if you:
Struggle with blood sugar dysregulation - kombucha in particular contains residual sugars and can aggravate blood sugar dysregulation in dysglycemic individuals.
Have histamine intolerance - fermented products contain histamine and could cause reactions in histamine sensitive people.
Struggle with FODMAPS - these drinks can trigger symptoms in those sensitive to FODMAPs
It's also worth being aware of toxic contamination risk - homemade kombucha and kefir risk mould contamination if improperly prepared. And bone broth can accumulate heavy metals, specifically lead.
What to focus on instead
Consuming kombucha, kefir or bone broth whilst the foundational dietary drivers of gut imbalances remain unaddressed will provide minimal benefit. True gut health support requires:
1. Reduction of the imbalance drivers (processed foods, excess sugar, chronic stress, insufficient fibre)
2. Adequate fibre from diverse whole foods to feed beneficial bacteria
3. Identification and elimination of food triggers
4. Repair of the gut lining through collagen-rich foods (bone broth included, but also other sources) and glutamine
5. Consideration of targeted probiotics if significant micrbiome imblanaces are confirmed
A glass of kefir or kombucha cannot substitute for this work.
For hormone balance, these drinks are essentially irrelevant. True hormonal support requires adequate calories, macronutrients, micronutrients (particularly iron, zinc, magnesium, B vitamins), sleep, and stress management. Gut health is supportive (through it's role in detoxing oestrogen), but the drinks are a minor layer atop this foundation.
If you do want to introduce gut health drinks, or any other fermented foods, then do so slowly. Start with 1-2 tablespoons and increase gradually as your tolerance improves. Ensure the products you choose are not pasteurised and that they contain no added sugars. Individual variation is enormous—some clients thrive with fermented foods; others find them trigger dysbiosis symptoms
Talk with me for free
Gut symptoms can feel exhausting, and it’s completely normal to reach for quick solutions. If you’d like clarity on what’s actually driving your digestion, bloating, or energy changes, I’d be happy to explore it with you in a supportive, personalised way.
Prefer to read at your own pace?
I share occasional, practical updates like this, and let people know when something new is published. You’re welcome to leave your email below